What Price Happiness?
A/N: Post KotOR II.
You know, when she told me I had to team up with the Disciple, I shoulda said no. Seriously.
See, she had this crystal she wanted. Querzite, I think she said. I don’t know, really. I just wrote down where she said to find it. That shoulda been the first tip-off, actually. It was on Korriban. Korriban!
First, the place is a desert. I hate deserts. In fact, hate isn’t even strong enough. Loathe. I’ve always wanted to use that word. I loathe deserts. Tatooine? You can keep it. Korriban? No way. Sand that burns your eyes and gets into every orifice and crevice; creatures that are just as nasty. Deserts just give me this weird sense of…of desperation, too. People who build their lives on such a shaky foundation as sand must be desperate.
What? I’m a Jedi, now; I’m allowed to spout insightful wisdom sometimes. I even refrained from mentioning that the only good thing about deserts is that the dancing twi’leks wear even smaller outfits. Cause it’s hot, heh.
Oh, yeah. Where was I? Second, I don’t really like the idea of going anywhere Sith-related anymore. That’s just a personal preference. I have a feeling that’s pretty much the case with all redeemed Sith. I bet even Revan prefers it, though she’d never say as much.
Anyway, I think you get the idea. The Exile even described it as "a simple mission."
Yeah, I definitely shoulda said no.
Instead, I asked, “Why can’t you go with me?” She just frowned at me and insisted that the council would be meeting for days on end, as usual, to discuss some kind of stupid rule change. Something about Jedi having kids or whatever. I didn’t really pay attention; she’s sort of distracting when her robes are fitting her just right and she smiles like that!
“Why can’t Visas do it?” Visas was on Katarr, trying to sort through the ruins of her species. Apparently, that’s really important work.
“Why can’t Mira and Bao-Dur do it?” They were on the surface of Telos, helping the Ithorians prepare for new zone openings. Again, Really Important Work.
So, I huffed a little, pouted, really tried to press the guilt thing, and then just said, “Fine.” She wanted to make it up to me by dragging me over to our bed—and an hour later, I did feel better…but only slightly. Another clue that this wasn’t a good idea? You betcha.
~*~
“You know, Atton, I’m the best Jedi in the galaxy and I do everything perfect and don’t you think my blonde hair is dreamy?”
What? That really does summarize most of what he said on any given day of the week. And I had to ride with him—the Disciple, Mical—in a tiny long-range shuttle for hours. When we finally arrived on Korriban, I was actually thankful!
He glanced at the map, looked around the valley of tombs for a minute, and then pointed. “That one.”
“Whose is it? Any idea?” Not that I was curious or anything.
“No. It is one of the many unnamed tombs in the area. This planet was blah, blah, blah.” He never knew when to shut up! Okay, so it was that smallish tomb with the door leading down into the ground instead of up some stairs. That’s really all I needed to know, thanks.
And whadaya know? It looked like it’d been looted, of course. Somebody left the front door wide open.
I went first, shivering when I entered. It wasn’t the musty, moldy air or the hollow silence of the place. Something deeper; the dark side, perhaps. It doesn’t really matter what that something was; it was just creepy.
We navigated the tomb easily enough, moving below the surface of Korriban as we did. Didn’t meet any kind of creature or sentient, not even a bug. In fact, as you probably already figured out, it was too easy. We basically walked in and picked up the crystal.
And that’s when things became much more difficult.
The crystal was stored in a box, plain and square, hidden in a recessed cabinet in a wall. I swear I looked it over: I checked for traps, pressure switches, lasers, all kinds of stuff. Nothing. But when I scooped the crystal up out of the box, I heard a squeak, a crack, a rumble, and a crash, real fast. When I turned around, I knew something was wrong, but what?
Disciple? Check.
Crystal? Check.
Strange, scary noise? Check. Crap.
I quickly surveyed the room again and realized what had happened. Both doors were blocked by two large, round stones. How’d they get there? Beats me, I was getting the crystal. And Disciple wasn’t any help, either. He was just staring at the wall beside one of the stones—the one covering our exit.
Facing the wall, his voice echoing all over the place, he just started talking. “Atton, I’m able to read the writing. I studied it in the academy archives, as there was little else to do while I waited for the Exile’s arrival. In fact, I was studying it when she knocked on the door of the archives—“
“Your point?” Oh, Force, let him have a point!
“This wall was uncovered when the stone was moved. It says ‘What price for a crystal so rare? One death; the Jedi key. Else, all shall perish here.’ What do you make of it?” He’d turned to face me at some point, but I was caught on the phrase ‘all shall perish here’ and didn’t notice.
“Did it mean one of us has to die or…uh…we both do?” If it was me or him, well, I think you can guess who I thought would win—er, hoped would, anyway. Something old and dark flared up inside of me and my finger twitched toward the blaster at my side, but I pushed it away, as usual, folding my hands in my lap.
“I-I believe so, Atton. There is smaller, supplementary text below, but I am having difficulty with one word and…oh.” The Disciple twitched, just a little. I only caught it because he always annoyed me with his little twitches and this was one of the really annoying ones: eyebrow-head-hand.
“What? What does it say?” I’d have been embarrassed by the edge of fear in my voice, in any other situation.
“Basically, we shall run out of oxygen in eight hours.”
“Unless one of us dies?”
“Unless one of us dies. Then, the door shall open.”
“So it’s all a big Sith joke, then? Ha.” He must have seen me eyeing him, because the Disciple’s frown deepened and he quietly suggested that we meditate in an effort to figure this out and conserve oxygen. I agreed ‘cause, well, we might figure something out. And the Exile would kill me if I came back without that smarmy dope.
We sat down on separate sides of the room, and I had every intention of meditating, but…but…I couldn’t. There was no way to find my focus in that place, so I paced instead, up and down the length of the room. I could think better like that. I could think better if I was back on the Hawk, lounging in the cockpit, and didn’t have another threat of impending doom hanging over my head. Ha! I could think better if I was back on Coruscant with the Exile and I’d said no to this dumb mission.
Of course, the Disciple was playing ‘Jedi Master’ in the other corner. Stiff-backed and still, just meditating.
The thought occurred to me that, if we both died, the Council would eventually send someone looking for us. If they found us, they'd probably see the Disciple and say something like, “Look, he died a true Jedi.”
Then, they’d find my body sprawled out somewhere and groan, “Oh, and Atton was there, too.” Gah!
~*~
After four hours, I was getting impatient. And tired. And hungry. And feeling really stupid. It was a door. We were Jedi. Surely there was something we could do besides stare at it. I found myself pacing, tracing the spaces between joints with my fingertips. Like that prison on Hilo, just needed to find a weakness. I even tried blasting it a few times with this cool Force-thing the Exile had shown me. Of course, it didn’t move.
The air was definitely thinner, and it was starting to taste suspiciously like stale caffa and eggs—breakfast that morning. A lone torch hung underneath the inscription, guttering and dancing, sending shadows across the walls. And I still don’t know if it was me or the room, but that place was getting smaller by the minute.
I wandered over to the Disciple, sort of contemplating kicking him to get him out of his trance. Instead, I squatted down in front of him. His eyes popped open immediately, wide and blue. Not that I noticed. “Think of anything?”
“No, Atton. I haven’t thought of anything since the last time you asked.” He sighed and just stared at me for moment. We had a sort of staring contest for minute before he turned away. I heard him saying something, so I leaned in a bit closer, resting on my knees and toes. “But I have been thinking about the Exile and, well, I need to ask a favor of you, Atton. If anything were to happen…if, for some reason, one of us doesn’t make it out of here…the other will take care of her, right? Promise me that you will?”
“But, Mical—“
“Atton, promise that you will. I love her, but I don’t make her happy. You do. I accepted it long ago. I know she has a temper, but you must understand the precious gift that she is. Should something happen…”
“Nothin’s gonna happen. We’ll figure something out, right?” The Disciple looked back at me, a hint of anger in his expression. “Okay, okay, I promise.”
I didn’t notice any change in him until he’d already moved, and frack if it wasn’t already too late. The next thing I knew, there was a blaster discharge and he was sprawled out on the stone floor, my blaster skittering across the room. It was obvious from the smell as I got closer that he’d emptied his bowels, and apparently his stomach as well by the stain on the ground beside him.
The worst thing was the way I hesitated for a minute, like I wasn’t gonna do anything. I mean, I didn’t like the guy, but…
“Hey, what are you tryin’ to pull here? Tryin’ to show me up? Stealin’ my glory?” I always covered everything up with stupid humor and sarcasm. This time, I couldn’t even manage the stiffest laugh, and something in me snapped.
I knelt down beside him and gathered his body up in my arms. That self-sacrificing little…“Why?”
The side of his head was ruined, burnt flesh, sodden with blood. “If, by saving you, I can ensure her happiness…I shall.”
Hell, what do you say to something like that?
His raspy breath was slowing down. I tried to feed him some of my own reserves of power, but the schutta blocked me. “…take care of them.”
My chest clenched as he said it because you could see the light go out behind those eyes of his. I guess he just needed to say it, before he let go.
I didn’t have time to think about it for long, though. This awful screeching noise filled my ears, the scraping of rock-on-rock. The door! Kriffing pretty-boy…I knew he saved my life, but, I mean, then I really knew! One death; the Jedi key. At the same time, he started glowing. Blue light surrounded him, and where it touched me, a warm calm seeped into my muscles. The light grew brighter until I had to close my eyes, and then the weight on my lap faded until there was nothing. When I could see again, it was just in time to see a blue Force-ghosty impression of the kid, disappearing.
I guess, in some weird way, I helped him find peace before he died. That’s what that means, right? I’ve heard of it, but all the Jedi I’ve ever seen, well, they went in a less-than-peaceful sort of way.
After a minute of stunned, gape-mouthed shock, I scrambled up off the ground, grabbed his lightsaber, and ran. Better to get outta there before I got into any more trouble. Besides, I had to get back to the Exile. I’d promised him, after all. And she’d wanna know. I found it hard to be sad; if the Disciple was one with the Force, then I was actually happy for him. It’s what he wanted, why he hung on until he knew she would be okay. Frig, he wasn’t as bad as I thought. Anyway, it wasn’t until months afterward that I was able to mourn properly, when I really understood what he’d done for us.
As I stomped up the shuttle’s boarding ramp, I couldn’t help thinking about his final words. He would be the type to leave behind some kind of legacy, promises to be fulfilled and stuff. He was just that way. In hindsight, I can see that it made a difference, but just then, I was pretty confused.
Something tugged at the back of my mind as I fired up the engines and started the pre-flight checks. The tug became a pull as I lifted off that Force-forsaken planet. The pull became an itch I couldn’t ignore as I made the jump to hyperspace and the stars became streaks. His last words...
"Take care of them?"

Your writing and ideas are
Your writing and ideas are solid as always. But my feelings about this piece are conflicted, because it feels like you're pulling in several different directions for this one. I'm going to try to explain, so please bare with me.
You've labeled this as angst and drama, but throughout to me, the tone feels comedic. I think it's because Atton seems to be constantly implying "Oh brother" or "why me?" very flippantly and you make full use of things like the comedic rule of three with,
"Disciple? Check.
Crystal? Check.
Strange, scary noise? Check. Crap."
Also, in terms of Atton, I'm seeing some major dysfunction and am not sure if it was intentional or not. The game paints Atton as a sociopath and all around sick puppy. I understand that your Exile is light side and made Atton a Jedi, but that just seems like it would add to Atton's baggage. If he were truly light sided and a Jedi and completely past what he was, I don't think he would be so flippant or cavalier about it all, so to see him behave that way it seems to me to be one of two things. Either the author willfully ignored that part of Atton's personality, because it wasn't conducive to romance or Atton's denying these things himself because they don't go hand in hand with what a Jedi's supposed to be and is on the verge of a complete and total meltdown or psychotic episode.
With Mical, him killing himself is not something I find myself buying into. It's an overly romanticized gesture, to sacrifice yourself for the happiness of the one you love, but it doesn't really fit with his character. The fascination with old relics that causes him to ramble on, the deciphering ancient languages, the meditating, yes. Despite the puppy dog exterior we're presented with, he's always struck me as someone that was intelligent, meticulous and most importantly, confident. You've got him pegged as such for the entire thing and then he pulls a 180 and whips out a blaster and kills himself. Maybe I'm just too cynical, but it's really hard to swallow someone taking their own life for the sake of an ex-girlfriend's (even one he views fondly) boyfriend.
Most appreciated!
Ah, I wasn't really sure what to label this thing. I agree. The effect didn't come off quite as planned.
I tried (tried) to portray Atton speaking and running his thoughts through a sort of "Atton filter". It's supposed to be like he's telling the story from some time in the future and not actually in the situation, so the urgency and darkness of the memories may have faded a bit. I've written some really scary Atton before, but this didn't seem like the place or time.
As for Mical, I tend to characterize him by the following conversation from in-game:
So, it seemed natural that he would do what it took to help her continue down her path. If Atton is a means to that end, so be it. It's not really about Atton, but about the Exile. And not really about love like the romantic kind, but a something else that drives Mical at the base of his in-game personality.
Hm. I see that I needed to make that more clear, and clean up his personality a bit.
I can see how it would come off that way, though that wasn't my intention.
Thank you for your thorough review. I have yet to write a challenge piece that I like as much as my normal writing and I'm at a loss as to why. In any case, I always appreciate feedback; anything to grow as a writer. :)
____________________
"If rain brings winds of change, let it rain on us forever." VNV Nation, Solitary
Well Done
I enjoyed this, as I do with all your work. I agree and disagree with Pluto on the comedy aspect of the piece, because while there is some humor, Atton has always struck me as one who uses sarcasm/comedy to hide his fear and/or angst he may have about a situation, thus it appears he never takes anything serious.
Also, as I read this and the One death; the Jedi key. Else, all shall perish here.’ I went back to the early part where Atton talks about avoiding the dark side and what popped into my mind, was that I wouldn't put it past him to embrace his dark side again and slay Mical, because I sensed genuine fear in having to return to Korriban. As for Mical . . . I can totally see himself sacrificing his life to save someone else, especially the Exile so that's not too much of a stretch for this.
Anyway, great job a usual.
I agree.
Aw, thank you.
This, in combination with the fact that he's telling the story in hindsight, was what I was going for. As I've mentioned in other replies, he was written after being run through an Atton-filter. Meaning, the way I thought he might see himself, and Disciple, and such. It doesn't mean it's actually how they are, just how he sees them. And he wouldn't dwell on darker aspects, I wouldn't think. But maybe I missed something there.
As for your second paragraph, it's exactly what I was thinking. :) I agree.
Of course, I also agree with most of what Prisoner and Plutospawn have said, too. I feel like something's missing.
Thank you very much for your review, as always.
____________________
"If rain brings winds of change, let it rain on us forever." VNV Nation, Solitary
I think you're cherry picking personality traits here.
I think I'm going to have to agree with pluts on this one. You're definitely a solid writer, and you have the basics of crafting a story, style, pacing etc down, but this story didn't work for me. Keep in mind that the following is simply one readers subjective opinion, so certainly feel free to take it or leave it as you please.
It seems to me like you're cherry picking from Atton and Disciples personality traits that are convenient to this story, and ignoring the parts of their personality and interactions that we see in the game when it isn't.
Atton, for instance, seems to be focused on the kinda goofy dufus/romance part of him that we see in the game. I realize he's been redeemed by this point, but still, darkness like that is something that someone carries with them forever. And as Pluts said, if Atton is really redeemed, this would affect him a lot more deeply - even if on the exterior he's all sarcasm and pretending not to care.
With Disciple, it's like you've chosen the worshipful part of his personality and expanded it into an almost golden retriever like devotion, where he's willing to lay down his life so she's happy. It's one thing to be devoted to someone. It's quite another to kill yourself so the woman you're devoted to can hook up with a dude you don't even like.
And that's another thing that is kind of ignored here - the animosity between Atton and Disciple that we see in the game. Even if they manage to somehow work it out, it still seems a stretch for Disciple to kill himself so this man he doesn't particularly respect can hook up with a woman he's supposed to be in love with. Especially when there's no hesitation about doing it and total and complete understanding and acceptance of the Exile and Atton's relationship (you'd think he'd be at least a tiny bit bitter here - especially since the exile is apparently knocked up with Atton's baby).
Anyway it didn't work for me, but others may disagree. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask.
Thank you.
I guess my vision of the Disciple comes from his conversation with Atton in which he says:
And Atton, himself, is passing through the Atton-filter as the story is told, so some of his baser traits were left out on purpose. I tried to imagine what he would think of himself (without being too angsty because, as a Jedi, he should be past the self-loathing, at least, I think, or determined not to focus on it).
As with the previous challenge, I'm only vaguely happy with this piece. I think it's better than the last, but not as good as my normal writing. I'm at a loss as to why my challenge entries are so "blah" to me. *sigh* Perhaps I try too hard? Hm...
Thanks for your honest critique and compliments. They are most appreciated, and I consider every review a chance to grow as a writer.
____________________
"If rain brings winds of change, let it rain on us forever." VNV Nation, Solitary
Well, everything I was
Well, everything I was thinking has more or less already been said -- including the part about you being a solid writer. This piece has its issues, but it is well-written. Good work, and keep at!
"Everything is a game -- a vile, evil, delightful game."
Thanks for your time.
Thank you for taking the time to read and review. I happen to agree with the others, as well. And the compliment is most appreciated. :)
____________________
"If rain brings winds of change, let it rain on us forever." VNV Nation, Solitary
Can't Really Add Much Here
One thing I want to add before I start. I'm not a fan of Mical/Atton pairings because they're all too cliched and usually one character ends up getting bashed while the other is gushed. I appreciate that you didn't do that and both characters are balanced here.
I can't add much here that isn't already said but I'll give it a shot. I more or less agree with Prisoner and Plutospawn amongst others. Really good writing in terms of plot and description and the characters weren't half-bad either. The problem is that they weren't complete. We saw some aspects of their personality while others were missing.
In Atton's case, people can change, yes, but only so much as to what they already have within them. People fall to the dark side through the demons they already possess within them and those demons don't go a way through redemption either. Simply put, they're still around but now they're controlled. "Once down the dark path, forever shall it dominate your destiny" or somesuch thing.
Basically, Atton's redeemed yes, which I buy because I believe in redemption but he's not "cured." Those sociopathic elements remain behind. It would have been nice to see some evidence of them, either through temptation to kill Mical off or through, on the other end, extreme shock at Mical's sacrifice. A redeemed Atton might have himself been have tempted to kill himself. After all, for all the confidence he exudes, he really hates himself deep down.
In the case of Mical the only thing that really bothered me about his character throughout the piece was his initial bit of narcissism, which hardly seems in character. Perhaps that was Atton's imagination but if so then it wasn't clearly indicated.
As to his death, I'm divided on that. On the one hand, I think it was a cheap way out of the mess and saved Atton the trouble of angsting over killing the Disciple. On the other hand, much as I didn't really like it I think Disciple is pretty similar to the Babylon 5 character Marcus, who pulled a similar stunt near the end of Season 4 for the show. Of course, I didn't think that death was well-written either.
All in all, good story, just with some rather nasty problems.
Thank you for your comments.
[First, if I come off cranky, it's because I think I might have the flu. Ugh. It's not you, by any means! :D]
I'm glad you thought I balanced Mical and Atton. It's a tough thing to do.
The thing that everyone seems to forget (or maybe I'm misunderstanding?) is that the story is told by Atton. It's not told by me, the fair and trustworthy narrator. So. I mean, anything about Mical is running through the Atton-filter first.
In fact, everything is. He does hint at the fact that, given the chance/need, he'd try to kill Mical. And his fear of falling is shown in his fear of Korriban. But, it's not a story in his head. He's telling it, which means bravado, exageration, and some lies. I don't see him preaching about the darkside when he's telling a story, but maybe that's me. I think he'd avoid the subject, when possible, even cutting it out of the story completely.
I sort of thought since it was him telling the story... :)
I guess I should have gone about this differently because, somewhere, I didn't explain something. It's a story Atton's narrating.
Hm. I've never watched Babylon 5, so I can't say anything on the comparison. However, I thought about the different ways it could end and Atton killing Mical was boring, to be honest. It was expected. Of course, changing this changed the tone and now it's miscategorized. Such is life, I suppose.
Meh. Having to explain the above is proof of that.
Thanks for taking the time to read. See my responses to the others if you're interested in the rest of my reasoning. I figured I wouldn't spam my own story with the same info. Invariably, I'm not nearly as happy with my challenge pieces as I am with my regular writing--I really wish I knew why. I appreciate your indepth review and will keep your suggestions and critique in mind. ^_^
[Again, sorry if anything sounds cranky. I sincerely hope not, but I feel pretty awful and my kids say I'm annoyed with everything. ^^;]
____________________
"If rain brings winds of change, let it rain on us forever." VNV Nation, Solitary
Poor Atton...
He's always about the rationalization, isn't he? Probably the only way he can deal with the load upon load of guilt...
As soon as I read this, I knew it would do well in this challenge - regardless of plot points, it's an emotional punch and leaves me gasping.
"If I love you, what business is it of yours?" - Goethe
His hands reinvent cool more often in a day than Wynton Marsalis has in a decade." - http://www.templeofchow.com/
Rationalize and compartmentalize.
"Regardless of plot points", haha. No, no, I know what you mean. Rationalize and compartmentalize; it's the only way. Thanks for taking the time to read and review. :)
____________________
"If rain brings winds of change, let it rain on us forever." VNV Nation, Solitary
Deep and Light
I totally love the way you blend the lightness of Atton's personality with the depth and seriousness of your topic.
Yagr isn't egotistical. He's just better than everyone else.
Thank you.
I thought he might tell the story, even a heavy story, with a light attitude. He does tend to make light of every situation and I didn't expect him to tell any story that would make him weepy (he'd just leave those details out or gloss over them). I'm glad you liked that. :)
____________________
"If rain brings winds of change, let it rain on us forever." VNV Nation, Solitary
Lene: an Atton/Kavar/Carth/Malak and Zared fangirl!